Articles of associationAlterationCourt of Appeal

Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa Ltd

[1900] 1 Chancery 65619002 min read
The case in brief30-second read
Facts
The company's articles provided a lien on partly-paid shares for debts owed by members. Zuccani, the sole holder of fully-paid shares and also a holder of partly-paid shares, died owing money to the company.
Issue
Whether the alteration of articles extending the lien to fully-paid shares was valid, and what test governs the validity of alterations to articles.
Held
Lindley MR held that the alteration was valid. The power to alter articles is a statutory power that must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole. On the facts, the alteration was general in its application (it applied to all fully-paid shareholders) and was genuinely for the company's benefit, not targeted at oppressing any individual.
Principle
The power to alter articles must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole
Cite this

Facts

  • The company's articles provided a lien on partly-paid shares for debts owed by members
  • Zuccani, the sole holder of fully-paid shares and also a holder of partly-paid shares, died owing money to the company
  • The company altered the articles to extend the lien to fully-paid shares as well
  • Allen (Zuccani's executor) challenged the alteration as not being bona fide

Issue

  1. Whether the alteration of articles extending the lien to fully-paid shares was valid, and what test governs the validity of alterations to articles.

Held

  • Lindley MR held that the alteration was valid. The power to alter articles is a statutory power that must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole. On the facts, the alteration was general in its application (it applied to all fully-paid shareholders) and was genuinely for the company's benefit, not targeted at oppressing any individual.

Ratio decidendi

The statutory power to alter articles by special resolution is subject to one fundamental limitation: it must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole. The court will not inquire into the motives of individual shareholders unless the alteration is so oppressive that no reasonable person could consider it to be for the company's benefit. An alteration that is general in its scope and genuinely aimed at the company's commercial interest will be upheld even if it incidentally prejudices a particular member.

Exam use

How to use it in an answer

  • This is the foundational case on the test for valid alteration of articles. Use it in questions about majority power vs. minority protection, the "bona fide for benefit of company as a whole" test, and the limits of the statutory power to alter articles.
  • Key quotable line: "The power to alter articles must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole."

Cite this

Citation

Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa Ltd [1900] 1 Chancery 656

Reported: Chancery Reports. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.