DomicileResidenceSupreme Court of India

Pradeep Jain v Union of India

AIR 1984 SC 142019841 min read
The case in brief30-second read
Facts
State governments imposed domicile or residence requirements for admission to medical and engineering colleges. Students challenged these as violative of Art.14 and Art.15(1).
Issue
Whether domicile or residential requirements for admission to educational institutions are constitutionally permissible, and what the distinction between domicile and residence is.
Held
Domicile requirements are impermissible for admission to educational institutions as they constitute a restriction on the basis of place of birth under Art.15(1). Reasonable residence requirements are permissible as they serve a legitimate State interest. The Court discussed the distinction between domicile (a legal concept of permanent home) and residence (a factual concept of physical presence).
Principle
Domicile and residence requirements for educational admissions must be reasonable; the case is cited in family law for its discussion of domicile as a connecting factor and the distinction between domicile and mere residence.
Cite this

Facts

  • State governments imposed domicile or residence requirements for admission to medical and engineering colleges. Students challenged these as violative of Art.14 and Art.15(1).

Issue

  1. Whether domicile or residential requirements for admission to educational institutions are constitutionally permissible, and what the distinction between domicile and residence is.

Held

  • Domicile requirements are impermissible for admission to educational institutions as they constitute a restriction on the basis of place of birth under Art.15(1). Reasonable residence requirements are permissible as they serve a legitimate State interest. The Court discussed the distinction between domicile (a legal concept of permanent home) and residence (a factual concept of physical presence).

Ratio decidendi

(1) Domicile is a legal concept connoting a permanent home with the intention to remain indefinitely. (2) Residence is a factual concept connoting physical presence without the animus of permanence. (3) The two are not interchangeable and serve different legal purposes.

Exam use

How to use it in an answer

  • Cite for the distinction between domicile and residence in a family law context
  • Relevant to the SMA S.5 thirty day residence requirement (which is residence, not domicile)
  • Relevant to the IDA S.2 domicile requirement (which is domicile, not residence)

Cite this

Citation

Pradeep Jain v Union of India AIR 1984 SC 1420

Reported: AIR 1984 SC 1420. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.