Property lawTPAPunjab and Haryana High Court

Smt. Vidya v Smt. Parmila

AIR 2007 P&H 13220071 min read
The case in brief30-second read
Facts
A gift deed was registered in favor of the donee. The donee took possession and lived in the property for years. The donee never signed a separate "acceptance" document.
Issue
Whether acceptance of a gift requires a separate written or express declaration, or can it be implied from conduct.
Held
Acceptance can be implied. Taking possession of gifted property and exercising ownership rights (living in it, making improvements, paying taxes, asserting title) constitutes implied acceptance. A separate document of acceptance is not required.
Principle
Acceptance of a gift can be implied from conduct such as taking possession, making improvements, and asserting ownership
Cite this

Facts

  • A gift deed was registered in favor of the donee
  • The donee took possession and lived in the property for years
  • The donee never signed a separate "acceptance" document
  • The donor's heirs challenged the gift claiming absence of formal acceptance

Issue

  1. Whether acceptance of a gift requires a separate written or express declaration, or can it be implied from conduct.

Held

  • Acceptance can be implied. Taking possession of gifted property and exercising ownership rights (living in it, making improvements, paying taxes, asserting title) constitutes implied acceptance. A separate document of acceptance is not required.

Ratio decidendi

S.122 requires acceptance but does not prescribe the form of acceptance. Acceptance may be express (written/oral declaration) or implied (conduct inconsistent with non-acceptance). The key test is whether the donee's actions demonstrate an intention to accept the gift.

Exam use

How to use it in an answer

Use in problems where donee does not formally accept but exercises ownership. Key line: "Taking possession + exercising ownership = implied acceptance of gift."

Cite this

Citation

Smt. Vidya v. Smt. Parmila AIR 2007 P&H 132

Reported: Avatar Singh, Law of Transfer of Property. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.